Author: Peter van Kets
On Culture and Leadership, WHAT COULD POSSIBLY BE SAFER THAN A RIGID RULE…? Can debate produce greater safety than rules? Isn’t the iron-clad rule a surer safeguard against disaster? We tend to think of organisations like NASA as having more or less the same basic character despite the passage of years. But it’s not necessarily […]
On Culture and Leadership, WHAT COULD POSSIBLY BE SAFER THAN A RIGID RULE…?
Can debate produce greater safety than rules? Isn’t the iron-clad rule a surer safeguard against disaster?
We tend to think of organisations like NASA as having more or less the same basic character despite the passage of years. But it’s not necessarily so. All organisations accumulate rules over time, and when left unchecked, these rules can fundamentally alter the nature of any organisation.
When NASA faced two separate, well-known challenges, their culture at each stage was very different.
In 1970, Apollo 13 was two days into its mission. While the astronauts on board hurtled towards the moon at 2 000 miles per hour, an explosion knocked out one of their oxygen tanks, leading Commander James Lovell to utter the now iconic statement, ‘Houston, we have a problem.’
The ensuing creative scramble to get the astronauts safely home is the stuff of legend. Just about everything that could go wrong did.
The creative trial and experimentation that went into rescuing the astronauts was formidable. New procedures were made up back on earth, then quickly tested in the simulator, then relayed to the astronauts 200 000 miles away, almost in real-time.
Yet through this process of creative trial and experimentation, of collaborative interdisciplinary debate, one by one the issues were resolved, and, ultimately, the crew was brought home safely.
…And here’s why:
At this point in time, NASA’s culture was ruled by imaginative debate. It was an exploratory culture, an experimenting culture, a culture based on learning and evolution, in which, every day, every new exercise and every new thing learnt was prodded and handed around like a toddler in a mommies’ group.
Even though the mission essentially failed, NASA nevertheless classified it as a ‘successful failure’, because of the experience gained and lessons learnt while rescuing the crew.
The alternative
By contrast, at the time of the Columbia disaster of 2003, the culture of experimentation had given way to one of formalised rules, regimented procedures and rigid hierarchy. One could argue that NASA had stopped being a learning organisation. It had become a bureaucracy instead.
As Columbia re-entered the earth’s atmosphere, a large piece of foam fell from the shuttle’s external tank and broke the wing of the spacecraft. First, atmospheric gasses entered the cabin, then the shuttle itself broke into pieces.
NASA recovered 84 000 pieces from a debris field of over 2 000 square miles.
The investigation into the disaster was exhaustive. Besides the physical cause of the accident, investigators made some damning remarks about the culture that led to the problem. Reliance on past success had become a substitute for true learning.
During a post-launch review, a group of engineers actually saw this foam dislodge from the rocket. They tried to pass on this information, and voiced their concern about it.
NASA’s management, which by this stage liked to manage everything ‘by the rules’, had seen dislodged foam before, and, according to their institutionalised perceptions, deemed it to be unimportant.
The engineers tried to argue that it seemed like a lot more foam than usual. It was a qualitative argument, based on human insight and intelligence. But NASA was unable to listen. The set-in-stone norms had it that dislodging foam was a known quantity, and the voices of the engineers went unheeded.
NASA by this stage was so bound in rules and procedures that, in important ways, it had ceased to be a learning, experimenting culture. Now it was an unheeding, process-following one. And that made it incapable of hearing an idea, to its great detriment.
Situational awareness:
The best and most agile organisations are not run by rigid rules. Instead, they favour imaginative debate. Encouraging imaginative debate allows situational awareness to pass up and down the chain of command. It promotes the opportunity to see innovation possibilities, and it becomes a safeguard against unexpected problems.
And so, a simple test: Which culture prevails in your organisation today? Imaginative debate? Or rigid rules? If it’s the latter, remember: They’re your rules. You can break them.
Douglas Kruger specialises in dismantling needless rules. A business speaker and author of 9 books with Penguin Random House, including ‘They’re Your Rules, Break Them!’, and the global publication, ‘Virus-Proof your Small Business.’ He speaks on leadership, culture, disruptive innovation and how to reduce your own rules for greater efficacy. Douglas is also a multiple award-winning speaker, who was inducted into the ‘Speakers Hall of Fame’ in 2016.
Contact Us at WeSpeak Global and follow us on Facebook
Video
The articles, video and images embedded on these pages are from various speakers and talent.
These remain the property of its owner and are not affiliated with or endorsed by WeSpeak Global.
The Mindset That Makes Me a Successful Speaker and communicating well have been integral parts of my identity for as long as I can remember. Whether it was a classroom full of my peers back in school or an auditorium full of strangers at a big event, there has always been something immensely fulfilling about […]
Some people see the glass as half full, others see it as half empty, but I just gulp it down and ask for more Optimistic During Setbacks. Life is a smorgasbord, and even though some servings are tough to swallow, you need to power through it in order to enjoy dessert. Enough with the food […]
We are all ordinary and can ACHIEVE THE EXTRAORDINARY. Every single one of us is an ordinary person who has a set of talents, opportunities, challenges and experiences to work with. Whether we turbocharge those into greatness or lie on the couch is usually entirely up to us. But to start with, we are all […]
17The Wonderbag is up for yet another accolade; the Food Planet Prize rewards excellence in environmental-based food innovation. South Africa (14 September 2022) – Wonderbag, a South-African-based startup founded by social entrepreneur Sarah Collins, has developed a simple yet pioneering cooking tool that continues to cook food which has been brought to boil by conventional methods. […]
Did you hear the fascinating story of The Profitability of Integrity about the French mountaineer who found a box of precious gems and decided to do something most wouldn’t do? Read on! ~ Can you make money from your Integrity? I stand firm in the belief that people do business with those they TRUST, can […]
BEING MINDFUL OF MINDSETS and The Power of a Growth Mindset by Grant Driver In July 2019, I experienced one of the most significant and yet most daunting moments of my career as a professional speaker. I had been invited by Discovery Healthcare to present a 3-hour workshop to thirty Neurosurgeons on my research into […]
Care About and Challenge Each Other – The Two Keys to Team Performance I’ve been a part of lots of teams, in sports and business, and over the past 20 years I’ve had a chance to work with many high-performing teams, at companies like Google, Wells Fargo, Microsoft, Schwab, eBay, and others. I’ve also studied […]
It has been said that “one should never let A Good Crisis go to waste”. I am an eternal optimist and I believe that in the midst of any crisis is opportunity. My diary has gone from an anxiety-inducing jam-packed schedule for the next month to having most meetings and events cancelled. Many people are […]
No results available
Our Mission
© All rights reserved 2025. Created using VOXEL THEME